What Are the Current Tariffs on Silver and Gold in Canada?
Recent Tariff Implementation
The recent implementation of a 25% tariff on certain commodities crossing the US-Canada border has created significant uncertainty in the precious metals market. These tariffs are part of a broader US initiative aimed at bringing manufacturing back to the United States. The response from Canadian government officials has been swift, with the premiers of Ontario and Alberta publicly expressing concerns about the economic impact of these measures.
Canadian mining companies are particularly concerned about how these tariffs on silver and gold in Canada might affect their operations and profitability. The lack of clarity in the tariff framework has left many businesses in limbo, unsure of how to plan their future shipments and processing strategies.
Impact on Precious Metals
There is considerable uncertainty surrounding whether silver and gold are specifically included in the new tariff structure. According to industry sources, First Majestic Silver Corp., one of Canada's leading silver producers, has not yet tested shipping metals across the border since the implementation of these tariffs.
"The lack of transparency in the tariff framework has created significant confusion for mining companies," notes Keith Neumeyer, CEO of First Majestic Silver. "We're operating in an environment where the rules are unclear, which makes business planning extremely difficult."
The ambiguity is particularly problematic for companies that have established supply chains spanning across North America, with mining operations in Mexico, processing facilities in the United States, and corporate headquarters in Canada.
How Do These Tariffs Affect Silver Producers?
Operational Challenges
Companies like First Majestic that typically ship silver to US refineries, such as Asahi in Salt Lake City, now face potential 25% tariff costs. This additional expense would significantly impact the economics of shipping to US refineries, potentially making such arrangements financially unfeasible.
The ripple effects extend beyond mining companies. US manufacturers who use silver for circuit boards, windows, and various coating products would face higher input costs, potentially leading to increased prices for consumers or reduced profit margins for businesses.
"A 25% tariff would completely change our calculus when it comes to where we process our silver," explains Neumeyer. "What was once an optimal solution may no longer make economic sense under these new conditions."
Alternative Supply Routes
In response to the tariff uncertainty, mining companies are actively considering bypassing US refineries entirely. As Neumeyer points out, "We could bypass the United States… there are refineries in Canada."
Rerouting silver from Mexico directly to Canada is becoming a viable alternative despite incremental cost increases. This strategy would allow companies to maintain their profit margins while avoiding the potential tariff burden, though it would represent a significant shift in established supply chains.
Industry analysts suggest that such rerouting could have long-term implications for US refineries, potentially leading to reduced business and job losses in the American precious metals processing sector.
What Is the Current State of the Silver Market?
Supply-Demand Fundamentals
The silver market is currently experiencing its fifth consecutive year of structural deficit, with demand outpacing supply by a significant margin. A recent TD Bank report warns of a potential liquidity crisis in silver, highlighting the growing imbalance in this critical market.
Despite these strong fundamentals, the silver price remains significantly undervalued compared to gold. The current gold-to-silver ratio is approximately 90:1, which industry experts like Neumeyer consider "absolutely ridiculous" given the relative scarcity and industrial importance of silver.
"Historically, the gold-to-silver ratio has been closer to 15:1," notes Neumeyer. "The current disparity suggests that either gold is overvalued or, more likely, silver is dramatically undervalued based on its supply-demand fundamentals."
Industrial Demand Factors
Silver's importance extends far beyond its traditional role as a precious metal. It is now a strategic metal required for virtually all electrical products, from smartphones to electric vehicles.
The energy sector expansion, whether renewable or nuclear, requires significant silver inputs. US energy production goals could require three times current capacity, all of which would need silver components. For context, a single solar panel contains approximately 20 grams of silver, while an electric vehicle uses between 25-50 grams of the metal.
The growing adoption of electric vehicles, with global sales rising by over 35% in 2023, is creating additional demand pressure on silver. This factor alone could potentially consume an additional 90 million ounces of silver annually by 2030, further exacerbating the supply deficit.
How Do Banking Practices Affect Silver Pricing?
Paper vs. Physical Markets
One of the most unusual aspects of the silver market is the vast disparity between physical and paper trading. For every 1 ounce of physical silver sold, approximately 350 times that amount trades in paper contracts. This means silver trades about 1 billion ounces daily in paper markets, amounting to 240 billion ounces annually.
This figure becomes even more striking when compared to global mining production, which is only about 830 million ounces annually. This massive disparity creates price suppression mechanisms that have kept silver prices artificially low despite strong physical demand.
"The paper market for silver has completely disconnected from physical reality," explains Neumeyer. "You have hundreds of paper claims for each ounce of physical silver, which is not sustainable in the long run."
Market Manipulation Concerns
There are persistent concerns that banks actively work to "protect their book" through various market mechanisms. During price spikes, such as the Reddit-driven squeeze in 2021, banks reportedly "printed millions of contracts" to cap the price and prevent a potential short squeeze.
Retail investor demand is considered the "inelastic part" that disrupts bank trading strategies. Unlike institutional investors who may trade based on technical factors, retail buyers often purchase physical silver based on fundamental value, removing it from the market entirely.
Industry observers note that banks use media and headlines to "dissuade" retail investors from entering the physical market. This includes promoting narratives about silver's volatility or downplaying its investment potential compared to other assets.
What Are Silver Industry Experts Forecasting?
Price Predictions
Despite the current market dynamics, silver industry experts remain bullish on the metal's prospects. Keith Neumeyer predicts $40 silver by the end of the year, representing a significant increase from current levels.
Long-term, the potential for "triple-digit silver" remains the forecast among industry insiders, though this would require breaking through current resistance levels around $34-35. Such a move would likely coincide with gold reaching new all-time highs, with some analysts projecting $3,200 gold by year-end.
"The fundamentals for silver have never been stronger," states Neumeyer. "The combination of industrial demand growth and investment interest creates a commodity super cycle for higher prices."
Supply Chain Disruptions
Industry experts anticipate potential manufacturing disruptions due to silver shortages. Major technology manufacturers like Apple could face production halts due to silver supply constraints, particularly as competition for available supply intensifies.
The limited transparency about actual silver content in consumer products contributes to market misunderstanding. For example, few consumers realize that a typical smartphone contains about 0.34 grams of silver, which translates to millions of ounces when considering global production volumes.
The Silver Institute has been criticized for doing a "terrible job in accumulating the data" about actual demand, potentially leading to market mispricing and eventual supply shocks when the true demand picture becomes apparent.
How Are Mining Companies Responding to Market Conditions?
Direct-to-Consumer Strategies
In an innovative move, First Majestic opened its own mint to sell directly to retail investors, bypassing traditional market channels. Approximately 5% of the company's silver production now flows directly to retail investors, who pay premiums well above the spot price.
This strategy aims to "break" the paper market's control over pricing by establishing direct relationships with end users. Retail investor demand fluctuates with price movements, with interest typically surging during price dips and market volatility.
"By selling directly to consumers, we're creating a parallel market that better reflects the true value of physical silver," explains Neumeyer. "The premiums consumers are willing to pay—often 25-30% above spot—tell the real story about silver's value."
M&A Activity in the Silver Sector
Significant consolidation is occurring in the silver mining industry as companies position themselves for anticipated higher prices. First Majestic acquired Gatos Silver for $970 million in January, representing one of the largest transactions in the sector.
This acquisition increases First Majestic's production from 21 million to 31-32 million ounces of silver equivalent annually, positioning it as one of the largest primary silver producers globally. The company's revenue is projected to grow from under $600 million to over $800 million by 2025 as a result.
Industry analysts expect more consolidation as larger mining companies seek to secure quality silver assets in stable jurisdictions, particularly as concerns about resource nationalism and Trump's commodity policies increase the value of operations in North America.
FAQ About Silver and Gold Tariffs in Canada
Are silver and gold specifically named in the new tariff structure?
The tariff framework lacks transparency regarding precious metals. Mining executives report uncertainty about whether silver and gold shipments will face the 25% tariff when crossing into the United States. This ambiguity has created a wait-and-see approach among producers who are reluctant to test the system until more clarity emerges.
How would tariffs on silver affect US manufacturing?
Silver is essential for electronics, solar panels, medical devices, and numerous industrial applications. A 25% tariff would significantly increase manufacturing costs for US companies that rely on silver inputs, potentially causing production delays or price increases. Industries particularly affected would include renewable energy, medical technology, and electronics manufacturing, all of which require silver for their products.
What alternatives do Canadian and Mexican silver producers have?
Producers can bypass US refineries by shipping directly to Canadian refineries. While this may involve slightly higher shipping costs, it would avoid the prohibitive 25% tariff, though this would ultimately reduce US refining business. Some companies are also exploring refining options in Asia, particularly South Korea and Japan, as part of a broader strategy to diversify their processing partners.
How do tariffs on commodities affect inflation?
According to industry experts, tariffs on essential commodities like metals and energy products typically create inflationary pressure in both the importing and exporting countries, hurting consumers and businesses in both nations. The added costs are generally passed along the supply chain, ultimately resulting in higher prices for finished goods containing these metals. For investors interested in this sector, understanding both global market insights and geopolitical investor strategies is essential, particularly when considering a comprehensive mining stocks guide for their portfolio.
Ready to Profit from the Next Major Mineral Discovery?
Get ahead of the market with instant alerts on significant ASX mineral discoveries through Discovery Alert's proprietary Discovery IQ model, turning complex data into actionable investment insights. Explore why historic discoveries can generate substantial returns by visiting Discovery Alert's dedicated discoveries page and begin your 30-day free trial today.
