Central Bank Gold Strategies Drive 2025 Market Transformation

Central bank gold purchases illustrated with map.

Central Bank Gold Purchases: Strategic Portfolio Positioning in an Era of Monetary System Transformation

The global monetary system stands at a critical inflection point where traditional reserve currency arrangements face unprecedented challenges from technological disruption, geopolitical realignment, and structural economic imbalances. Within this evolving landscape, central bank gold purchases represent sophisticated portfolio rebalancing strategies that extend far beyond conventional asset allocation models. These institutions, collectively managing over $13 trillion in reserves, are systematically repositioning their holdings to navigate an era characterised by monetary policy uncertainty, currency volatility, and diminishing confidence in established financial architectures.

What Economic Forces Are Driving Central Bank Gold Accumulation Strategies?

Monetary Policy Divergence and Currency Debasement Risks

Central banking institutions across different economic regions increasingly operate under conflicting monetary frameworks, creating persistent currency volatility and reserve management challenges. According to the World Gold Council, central banks purchased 1,037 tonnes of gold in 2022, marking the highest annual total since 1967. This accumulation pattern reflects systematic responses to what monetary policymakers characterise as "currency debasement risks" emerging from sustained fiscal deficits and accommodative monetary policies.

The mechanics of currency debasement operate through multiple channels that directly impact reserve adequacy calculations. Furthermore, these mechanisms create compelling conditions for precious metal allocation:

• Purchasing power erosion through sustained inflation above policy targets
• Real interest rate compression reducing fixed-income reserve yields
• Monetary base expansion outpacing economic growth trajectories
• Cross-border capital flow distortions from divergent policy implementations

Reserve managers evaluate gold's fixed supply characteristics against unlimited fiat currency creation potential, particularly when major reserve-issuing economies implement quantitative easing programmes. The International Monetary Fund reported that global central bank reserves totalled approximately $13.5 trillion as of Q2 2023, with gold constituting an increasingly significant component of diversification strategies during periods of monetary policy divergence.

Historical analysis demonstrates that central banks systematically increase precious metal allocations when policy rate differentials exceed 200-300 basis points between major economies. Consequently, this reflects institutional recognition that currency volatility creates reserve value preservation challenges across multi-year horizons.

Geopolitical Fragmentation and Reserve Currency Diversification

The architecture of global reserve currency arrangements undergoes structural transformation as geopolitical tensions reduce institutional confidence in cross-border financial systems. IMF COFER (Currency Composition of Official Foreign Exchange Reserves) data indicates the US dollar's share of global reserves has declined from approximately 71% in 2001 to lower levels in recent years, as central banks implement systematic diversification protocols.

Gold's appeal within diversification frameworks stems from its unique characteristics as a "neutral reserve asset" that carries no sovereign credit risk or monetary policy exposure. Emerging market central banks account for approximately 50% of global gold reserves growth, according to record-high gold prices analysis, reflecting strategic positioning against reserve currency concentration risks.

Reserve diversification strategies encompass multiple asset categories:

  1. Alternative currency holdings (euros, Swiss francs, Chinese yuan, Japanese yen)
  2. Precious metal allocations (gold, silver, platinum reserves)
  3. Real asset exposure (commodities, infrastructure, strategic materials)
  4. Digital currency preparations (central bank digital currency research and development)

Central bank communications from emerging market economies explicitly reference "reserve independence" objectives, indicating institutional recognition that geopolitical fragmentation necessitates reduced dependency on traditional reserve currency arrangements. This strategic positioning extends beyond portfolio optimisation toward broader economic sovereignty considerations.

Inflation Hedge Positioning in Multi-Decade Economic Cycles

Central banking institutions increasingly adopt long-term analytical frameworks that incorporate multi-decade inflation cycles and purchasing power preservation requirements. World Gold Council research documents that gold's real return (inflation-adjusted) over 20-year periods averaged approximately 2-3% annually, supporting its institutional adoption as a strategic inflation hedge across extended time horizons.

The inflation hedging mechanism operates through gold's relationship with real interest rates (nominal rates minus inflation expectations). When real rates approach or exceed zero, gold's attractiveness diminishes relative to yield-generating assets. Conversely, negative real rate environments create favourable conditions for precious metal accumulation, as gold preserves purchasing power without generating interest income requirements.

Historical precedent demonstrates gold's effectiveness during sustained inflation periods. The 1970s inflation crisis witnessed gold prices appreciate from approximately $35 per ounce to over $800 by 1980, representing a 2,200% nominal increase during a decade characterised by monetary policy accommodation and fiscal expansion.

Central bank reserve managers evaluate inflation hedge positioning across multiple time frames:

• Short-term tactical allocation (1-3 year policy cycles)
• Medium-term strategic positioning (5-10 year economic cycles)
• Long-term structural preparation (20-30 year demographic and technological transitions)

Contemporary monetary environments characterised by sustained fiscal deficits, demographic transitions, and technological disruption create conditions where inflation pressures may persist across multi-decade periods. Therefore, this enhances gold's strategic value proposition for institutional reserve management.

How Do Central Bank Gold Purchases Impact Global Market Dynamics?

Supply-Demand Imbalances and Price Discovery Mechanisms

Goldman Sachs recent analysis reveals fundamental shifts in gold market structure, with the institution raising its 2026 average gold price forecast to $4,450 per ounce from $4,000 previously. The projected trading range of $3,950 to $4,950 reflects recognition that central bank gold purchases have created systematic supply-demand imbalances that support elevated price discovery mechanisms.

Market analysts indicate that stabilising investor flow and technical measures suggest a positioning correction has completed following gold's recent retreat from record levels. Overall growth in demand outpaces supply, with third-quarter data demonstrating a continued central bank bidding presence that fundamentally alters traditional price formation processes.

The supply-demand imbalance manifests through several structural factors:

Market Component 2025 Impact Price Influence
Central Bank Purchases +15-20% YoY growth Strong upward pressure
Mining Production +2-3% capacity additions Limited supply response
Investment Demand Record Q3 levels Sustained price support
Industrial Consumption Stable baseline demand Neutral to positive

Gold prices reached a record high exceeding $4,380 per ounce before experiencing technical corrections, with current spot prices trading at approximately $4,188. This price action reflects the transition from surplus market conditions toward structural deficit scenarios where systematic central bank accumulation exceeds new supply additions from mining operations.

Price discovery mechanisms in contemporary gold markets operate through three primary channels: spot market transactions for physical gold delivery, futures markets establishing forward price signals through COMEX contracts, and central bank intervention signals that affect market expectations regarding sustained demand patterns.

Private Investor Sentiment and Institutional Flow Patterns

The expansion of gold prices into the $4,000+ range has broadened investor participation beyond traditional commodity trading constituencies, creating enhanced correlation between geopolitical risk events and precious metal inflows. Investment demand reached record levels during Q3 2025, driven by investors seeking safe-haven assets amid geopolitical tensions and concerns regarding long-term stability of traditional reserve currencies.

Institutional flow patterns demonstrate significant evolution as gold achieves historic gold surge levels:

• Exchange-traded fund (ETF) holdings expanding through sustained inflow periods
• Futures positioning indicating institutional participation beyond commercial hedging
• Physical bar flows showing increased vault storage and refinery production
• Retail investor engagement accelerating through precious metal dealers and storage services

The correlation between equity market volatility and gold inflows has intensified, with institutional investors implementing portfolio insurance strategies that automatically trigger precious metal allocations during periods of financial market stress. This systematic approach creates predictable demand patterns that support price stability during correction phases.

Private investor sentiment reflects growing recognition that gold's role extends beyond traditional commodity speculation toward strategic portfolio positioning for wealth preservation objectives. Safe-haven flows intensify during periods characterised by currency volatility, regulatory uncertainty, and geopolitical risk escalation.

Mining Sector Investment Implications and Production Responses

Gold prices exceeding $4,000 per ounce create substantial improvements in mining sector economics, with all-in sustaining costs (AISC) typically ranging from $800-$1,400 per ounce for major producers. However, production response to price increases operates on extended timelines due to exploration, permitting, and development requirements that span 5-10 year cycles.

The mining investment cycle encompasses multiple phases with distinct capital requirements:

  1. Exploration phase (3-5 years): Geological assessment and resource estimation
  2. Permitting and planning (2-4 years): Environmental approvals and engineering design
  3. Development and construction (3-6 years): Infrastructure development and facility construction
  4. Production phase (10-30+ years): Operational extraction and processing

Historical precedent from previous gold rallies demonstrates that price increases to $1,900+ levels (2011-2012) required 5-7 years to materialise in significant production capacity additions. Contemporary mining operations face additional constraints from environmental regulations, social licence requirements, and capital availability limitations that may extend development timelines further.

Mining sector investment decisions incorporate multiple variables beyond commodity price levels:

• Regulatory environment stability and permitting predictability
• Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) compliance requirements
• Infrastructure availability including power, transportation, and water access
• Geopolitical risk assessment for operations in emerging market jurisdictions
• Capital market conditions affecting project financing availability

The Langer Heinrich Mine operations in Namibia demonstrate sustained investment in African mining infrastructure despite regulatory challenges, indicating institutional confidence in long-term commodity demand trajectories. However, the timeline disconnect between price signals and production response creates conditions where supply constraints may persist across multi-year periods, supporting elevated price environments.

Which Regional Central Banking Strategies Are Reshaping Gold Markets?

Emerging Market Reserve Diversification Programmes

Emerging market central banks have emerged as the primary drivers of global gold accumulation, implementing systematic diversification programmes that reduce reserve concentration in traditional currencies. Poland's announcement of a 30% allocation target for gold represents one of the most aggressive reserve rebalancing initiatives, reflecting strategic positioning for monetary independence and external shock protection.

Regional Gold Purchase Volumes and Strategic Positioning:

Country Purchase Strategy Allocation Target Timeline
Poland Systematic accumulation 30% of total reserves Multi-year programme
Kazakhstan Strategic diversification 15-20% target range Ongoing implementation
Brazil Reserve rebalancing 10-15% allocation Phased approach
Turkey Stability enhancement Variable based on conditions Event-driven purchases

These accumulation patterns reflect institutional recognition that traditional reserve management frameworks may prove inadequate during periods characterised by currency volatility, geopolitical tensions, and monetary policy divergence. The 30% allocation targets mirror historical precedents where precious metals represented 20-40% of central bank reserves during the gold standard era.

Emerging market reserve diversification operates through multiple strategic objectives:

• External shock protection against reserve currency volatility
• Monetary policy independence from external central bank decisions
• Strategic asset accumulation during favourable pricing periods
• Economic sovereignty enhancement through reduced dependency on foreign monetary systems

Kazakhstan's central bank has implemented systematic gold purchasing protocols as part of broader commodity-based reserve strategies, recognising the country's natural resource endowments and geographic positioning between major economic powers. Brazil's approach emphasises gradual rebalancing to avoid market disruption while achieving strategic diversification objectives.

Turkey's central bank represents a unique case study in defensive gold accumulation, with purchases accelerating during periods of currency instability and external pressure. This reactive approach contrasts with the systematic accumulation strategies employed by Poland and Kazakhstan, demonstrating varying institutional approaches to precious metal reserve management.

China's Multi-Decade De-Dollarisation Framework

China's systematic gold accumulation strategy represents the most significant challenge to existing global monetary architecture, with holdings reaching approximately 2,300 tonnes representing 7% of total reserves. The People's Bank of China conducted ten consecutive months of systematic purchases, demonstrating policy consistency and strategic commitment to reserve rebalancing across extended time horizons.

China's de-dollarisation framework operates through multiple institutional mechanisms:

  1. Reserve asset rebalancing toward gold and alternative currencies
  2. Payment system development through the Cross-Border Inter-bank Payment System (CIPS)
  3. Trade settlement diversification promoting yuan-denominated transactions
  4. Strategic partnership agreements with emerging market economies for bilateral trade arrangements

The systematic nature of Chinese gold purchases indicates policy execution rather than opportunistic trading, suggesting institutional commitment to structural monetary system transformation. China's 7% gold allocation remains substantially below historical US levels of approximately 55% during peak gold standard periods, indicating potential for continued accumulation.

Chinese central bank transparency regarding gold holdings contrasts with historical practices of limited disclosure, suggesting deliberate communication of reserve rebalancing intentions to global markets. This transparency supports market confidence in sustained demand patterns while signalling institutional commitment to precious metal accumulation strategies.

The Belt and Road Initiative correlates with commodity reserve positioning strategies, as China develops economic relationships with resource-producing nations that may facilitate continued gold accumulation through direct bilateral arrangements rather than open market purchases.

Advanced Economy Central Bank Positioning

Advanced economy central banks approach gold holdings with greater conservatism than emerging market counterparts, reflecting historical reserve currency status and institutional confidence in existing monetary structures. However, gold price forecast 2025 analysis indicates that anticipated US Federal Reserve rate cuts will continue supporting gold demand through 2026, as lower rates reduce opportunity costs associated with non-yielding assets.

The relationship between policy rates and gold pricing operates through several transmission mechanisms:

• Opportunity cost reduction as lower rates decrease fixed-income alternative yields
• Real interest rate compression when nominal rate cuts exceed inflation adjustments
• Currency effects where accommodative policy typically weakens reserve currencies
• Risk premium expansion as rate cuts signal economic uncertainty or monetary accommodation needs

European Central Bank policy discussions have addressed reserve composition relative to eurozone economic requirements, with gold holdings representing approximately 50% of total reserves. This substantial allocation reflects historical precedent and institutional recognition of gold's role in monetary system stability.

Federal Reserve policy rate expectations create direct implications for global gold demand patterns. When US policy rates decline relative to inflation expectations, real yields on Treasury securities diminish, reducing the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding gold reserves. This correlation mechanism explains why gold prices reached record levels amid anticipated Federal Reserve rate cuts.

Advanced economy central bank strategies emphasise stability and gradual adjustment rather than the rapid rebalancing approaches employed by emerging market institutions. The Federal Reserve maintains the world's largest gold reserve at approximately 8,133 tonnes, representing institutional recognition of precious metals' role in monetary system confidence even within reserve currency issuing economies.

What Price Scenarios Could Central Bank Demand Support Through 2026?

Goldman Sachs' $4,450-$4,950 Trading Range Analysis

Goldman Sachs' revised forecast establishes a $4,450 average price target for 2026, representing a significant upward adjustment from previous projections of $4,000. The projected trading range of $3,950 to $4,950 reflects institutional recognition that central bank gold purchases have fundamentally altered market dynamics beyond traditional supply-demand equilibrium models.

The bank's analysis indicates that stabilising investor flows and technical measures suggest a positioning correction has completed following gold's retreat from record highs exceeding $4,380 per ounce. This technical assessment supports scenarios where systematic central bank demand provides price floor support while investment demand creates potential for testing upper range boundaries.

Key factors supporting the elevated price range projection include:

• Sustained central bank bidding demonstrated through Q3 data
• Supply growth constraints relative to demand expansion
• Federal Reserve rate cut expectations reducing opportunity costs
• Geopolitical risk premiums supporting safe-haven demand
• Currency debasement concerns driving alternative asset allocation

The $4,950 upper range represents approximately 13% appreciation potential from current levels near $4,188, indicating institutional expectations for continued demand growth throughout 2026. This projection assumes central bank purchase patterns maintain current trajectories while private investor demand responds to ongoing monetary policy accommodation.

Technical Correction Completion and Positioning Reset

Market technical analysis suggests that gold's correction from record levels above $4,380 has created conditions supportive of renewed accumulation phases. The completion of positioning corrections indicates that speculative excess has been eliminated, establishing foundations for sustained advance based on fundamental demand factors rather than momentum trading.

Technical correction patterns in precious metals markets typically encompass:

  1. Initial momentum exhaustion as speculative positions reach extreme levels
  2. Profit-taking phases where early investors realise gains at record prices
  3. Consolidation periods allowing fundamental demand to establish new equilibrium
  4. Accumulation resumption supported by institutional and central bank purchasing

The current market structure indicates transition from correction phases toward accumulation, with central bank demand providing systematic support during periods of reduced speculative activity. This pattern creates favourable risk-reward scenarios for institutional investors seeking precious metal exposure at relatively attractive entry points.

Market positioning data suggests that speculative long positions have been reduced to manageable levels, eliminating potential sources of selling pressure during market volatility periods. This positioning reset enables renewed institutional accumulation without the overhead of excessive speculative involvement.

How Are Sanctions Risks and Financial Weaponisation Influencing Gold Strategy?

Dollar-System Vulnerability Assessment

Central banks increasingly evaluate reserve management strategies through the lens of financial system weaponisation risks, where traditional currency and securities holdings may become subject to sanctions, freezing orders, or confiscation during geopolitical conflicts. The utilisation of financial sanctions as geopolitical tools creates institutional demand for assets that operate independently of existing banking infrastructure and legal frameworks.

Gold's appeal within vulnerability assessment frameworks stems from its physical characteristics and global acceptance outside traditional financial systems. Unlike bank deposits, government securities, or electronic assets, physical gold holdings maintained within domestic storage facilities remain accessible regardless of external sanctions regimes or banking system restrictions.

Financial weaponisation mechanisms that influence central bank strategy include:

• Asset freezing orders preventing access to foreign-held reserves
• SWIFT system exclusion limiting cross-border payment capabilities
• Securities market restrictions affecting government bond liquidity
• Banking relationship termination reducing operational access to financial services

The assessment of dollar-system vulnerabilities extends beyond immediate sanctions risks toward broader concerns regarding currency issuer policy decisions. Central banks recognise that reserve currency status provides issuing nations with significant leverage over global monetary conditions, creating dependency relationships that may prove disadvantageous during periods of conflicting national interests.

Reserve managers implement risk mitigation strategies that reduce exposure to external policy decisions while maintaining liquidity and operational capabilities. Gold accumulation represents one component of broader diversification strategies designed to enhance monetary sovereignty and reduce dependency on foreign financial systems.

Alternative Settlement Mechanism Development

Central banks are actively developing alternative settlement mechanisms that reduce dependency on traditional dollar-based payment systems while accommodating increased gold-based transactions. These systems provide institutional infrastructure for precious metal settlement alongside conventional currency operations.

Alternative settlement development encompasses several technological and institutional innovations:

• Blockchain-based settlement platforms enabling direct precious metal transfers
• Bilateral clearing arrangements facilitating gold-for-goods transactions
• Regional payment systems supporting local currency and commodity settlement
• Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) potentially backed by gold reserves

The development of these mechanisms reflects institutional preparation for scenarios where traditional payment infrastructure may become unavailable or unreliable due to sanctions, technical disruptions, or geopolitical conflicts. Gold's role within alternative settlement systems provides flexibility and independence from external control.

China's Cross-Border Inter-bank Payment System (CIPS) demonstrates institutional commitment to payment infrastructure that operates independently of US-controlled systems like SWIFT. Similar initiatives among other central banks create network effects that enhance the viability of alternative settlement mechanisms.

What Portfolio Risk Management Principles Drive Central Bank Gold Allocation?

Long-Term Wealth Preservation Versus Short-Term Volatility Management

Central bank gold purchases strategies prioritise long-term wealth preservation objectives over short-term volatility minimisation, recognising that precious metals provide purchasing power protection across multi-decade horizons despite periodic price fluctuations. This approach reflects institutional investment horizons that extend beyond political cycles toward structural economic transition management.

Wealth preservation frameworks evaluate gold's performance across extended periods:

  1. Purchasing power maintenance relative to inflation and currency debasement
  2. Intergenerational value transfer across political and economic system changes
  3. Crisis period protection during systemic disruptions and institutional failures
  4. Technology transition hedging against digital disruption of monetary systems

Central banks accept short-term gold price volatility as acceptable given long-term preservation characteristics. Volatility tolerance reflects recognition that wealth preservation requires acceptance of periodic fluctuations in exchange for protection against more severe wealth destruction risks associated with currency debasement or systemic crisis events.

The time horizon framework distinguishes central bank gold allocation from commercial investment strategies that emphasise quarterly or annual performance optimisation. Central banks evaluate success over 10-30 year periods, focusing on maintaining reserve value across complete economic cycles rather than optimising returns within specific market environments.

Crisis Performance Characteristics and Liquidity Considerations

Gold's performance during financial crises provides central banks with portfolio protection that extends beyond traditional risk management frameworks. Historical analysis of major crisis periods demonstrates that gold typically maintains or increases value during events that create coordinated decline across conventional asset classes.

Crisis performance analysis encompasses multiple event categories:

• Financial system crises (2008 global financial crisis, European sovereign debt crisis)
• Geopolitical conflicts (regional wars, trade disputes, sanctions regimes)
• Currency crises (emerging market devaluations, reserve currency volatility)
• Inflation shocks (energy price spikes, supply chain disruptions, monetary policy errors)

During the 2008 financial crisis, gold appreciated approximately 25% annually while equity markets declined substantially and government bond yields compressed. This performance demonstrated gold's effectiveness as a crisis hedge during periods when traditional safe-haven assets provided limited protection.

Liquidity considerations for central bank gold holdings encompass both market liquidity and operational accessibility. Gold markets maintain substantial daily trading volumes exceeding $100 billion globally, providing institutional liquidity for large transactions. However, physical gold liquidation requires additional time and logistical coordination compared to securities transactions.

The liquidity framework recognises that crisis periods may involve precisely those circumstances where immediate asset liquidation becomes necessary. Gold's global acceptance and value stability provide operational flexibility during periods when conventional financial markets may experience disruption or reduced functionality.

How Should Investors Position for Sustained Central Bank Gold Demand?

Direct Gold Exposure Versus Mining Equity Strategies

Investors seeking exposure to sustained central bank gold purchases face strategic choices between direct precious metal ownership and mining equity investments, each offering distinct risk-return characteristics and operational considerations. Direct gold exposure provides pure commodity price sensitivity without company-specific risks, while mining equities offer leverage to gold prices alongside operational and management factors.

The gold-stock market dynamics demonstrate how mining equities typically exhibit 2-3x leverage to gold price movements during bull markets, amplifying both upside potential and downside risks. However, this leverage comes with additional operational, regulatory, and management risks that direct gold ownership avoids entirely.

Investment strategy comparison:

• Direct gold ownership through ETFs, physical bullion, or digital platforms
• Mining equity exposure through individual stocks or sector-focused funds
• Royalty and streaming companies offering leveraged gold exposure with reduced operational risk
• Precious metal derivatives enabling customised risk-reward profiles through options and futures

The choice between direct and equity exposure depends on investor risk tolerance, leverage preferences, and operational convenience requirements. Direct gold provides pure commodity exposure suitable for wealth preservation objectives, while mining equities offer growth potential aligned with operational excellence and resource development success.

Monitoring Central Bank Communication and Policy Signals

Successful positioning for sustained central bank demand requires systematic monitoring of official communications, policy statements, and reserve management disclosures that provide insights into institutional accumulation intentions. Furthermore, gold market analysis demonstrates how early identification of policy shifts enables advantageous positioning before broader market recognition creates price adjustments.

Key monitoring categories include:

• Reserve composition reporting through IMF and national central bank disclosures
• Official sector communications regarding monetary policy and reserve management objectives
• Geopolitical event analysis affecting reserve diversification urgency
• Economic data interpretation influencing central bank policy decisions

Central bank transparency varies significantly across jurisdictions, with some institutions providing detailed reserve composition data while others maintain strategic ambiguity regarding precious metal holdings. Consequently, investors must synthesise multiple information sources to develop comprehensive understanding of institutional demand trends.

The timing of central bank purchases often correlates with broader economic and geopolitical developments, creating opportunities for informed investors to position ahead of institutional demand acceleration. However, this requires sophisticated analysis capabilities and risk management frameworks suitable for volatile commodity markets.

In conclusion, central bank gold purchases represent a fundamental shift in global monetary system architecture, driven by currency debasement concerns, geopolitical fragmentation, and long-term wealth preservation objectives. These systematic accumulation strategies create sustained demand patterns that support elevated gold prices while providing diversification benefits for institutional portfolios navigating an era of monetary uncertainty and geopolitical realignment.

Ready to Capitalise on the Next Major Mineral Discovery?

Discovery Alert instantly alerts investors to significant ASX mineral discoveries using its proprietary Discovery IQ model, turning complex mineral data into actionable insights for both short-term trading opportunities and long-term investment positioning. Understand why historic discoveries can generate substantial returns by exploring Discovery Alert's dedicated discoveries page, showcasing exceptional outcomes, and begin your 30-day free trial today to position yourself ahead of the market through Discovery Alert.

Share This Article

Latest News

Share This Article

Latest Articles

About the Publisher

Disclosure

Discovery Alert does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information provided in its articles. The information does not constitute financial or investment advice. Readers are encouraged to conduct their own due diligence or speak to a licensed financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Please Fill Out The Form Below

Please Fill Out The Form Below

Please Fill Out The Form Below