De Beers’ Secret Diamond Discounts Create Market Tensions

De Beers Secretly Sells Discounted Diamonds to Selected Traders

In an unprecedented move, diamond giant De Beers has implemented a secretive sales strategy, offering substantial discounts to a select group of customers while maintaining official prices for others. This strategic pivot comes amid mounting market pressures and has created significant tensions within the industry. The approach represents a dramatic shift from the company's traditional sales model and signals deeper challenges facing the global diamond market.

What's Happening with De Beers' Diamond Sales?

The Secret Discount Strategy Revealed

De Beers has been quietly offering significant price reductions to a carefully selected group of customers through confidential arrangements. These transactions occur entirely outside the company's traditional sales framework and feature discounts ranging from 10-20% below the official rates published by the company. According to industry sources cited by Bloomberg News, these secretive arrangements have involved diamond sales worth hundreds of millions of dollars in recent months alone.

"De Beers has been selling rough diamonds at sharply marked-down prices to a small handful of customers to reduce inventories without openly cutting prices," reported Bloomberg News in May 2025. This approach allows the company to move significant inventory while attempting to maintain price stability in the broader market.

Traditional Sales Model vs. New Approach

For decades, De Beers has operated through a highly structured sales system, conducting approximately 10 formal sales events annually in Botswana. These events, known in the industry as "sights," bring together roughly 70 authorized buyers called "sightholders" who traditionally purchase diamonds at non-negotiable prices set by De Beers.

This rigid pricing structure has been the cornerstone of De Beers' market control strategy, allowing the company to maintain price stability across the diamond ecosystem. The new selective discounting approach represents a dramatic departure from this established system and indicates the severity of current market challenges.

Recent sales events have seen diminished participation as buyers increasingly balk at De Beers' official prices, which many consider disconnected from market reality. The growing gap between De Beers' posted prices and actual diamond values has prompted many sightholders to reduce purchases or skip sales events entirely, further pressuring the company to find alternative sales channels.

Why Is De Beers Taking This Unusual Approach?

The Diamond Market Crisis

The global diamond industry has been struggling through a prolonged demand slump that has caused significant price declines across all categories. While recent market indicators suggest the beginning of potential stabilization, the recovery remains fragile and uncertain. This market context explains De Beers' reluctance to implement across-the-board price reductions that could further destabilize the entire industry.

The company faces a delicate balancing act: needing to move inventory while avoiding actions that could trigger broader market devaluation. By limiting discounts to private arrangements with selected buyers, De Beers appears to be attempting to alleviate its inventory pressures without broadcasting weakness that could ripple throughout the diamond ecosystem.

Inventory Reduction Pressures

De Beers faces mounting pressure from its parent company, Anglo American Plc, to address its growing stockpile of unsold diamonds. Anglo American announced plans last year to divest its diamond business as part of a broader corporate restructuring strategy, creating urgent demands for De Beers' management to improve financial performance ahead of the potential sale.

This pending divestiture has intensified the need for De Beers to demonstrate healthier inventory levels and more sustainable sales patterns. The secret discount strategy appears designed to reduce stockpiles without publicly acknowledging the market weakness that necessitates such measures.

The Pricing Dilemma

The company finds itself caught between competing imperatives: maintaining price stability in the broader market while addressing its own mounting inventory challenges. This dilemma stems from De Beers' historical role as a price stabilizer in the diamond market, where its published rates have traditionally served as benchmarks for the entire industry.

"De Beers faces a fundamental dilemma: needing to move inventory without officially lowering prices to avoid destabilizing a market already struggling with confidence issues," noted industry analysts in Bloomberg's May report.

The gap between De Beers' official prices and actual market valuations has grown significantly over the past year, creating an unsustainable tension that the company is now attempting to resolve through these selective, confidential arrangements with trusted partners.

How Are These Secret Sales Affecting the Diamond Industry?

Growing Tensions Among Buyers

The selective discounting strategy has created significant friction within De Beers' customer base. Buyers who haven't been selected for the discounted deals are expressing mounting frustration over what they perceive as preferential treatment that creates uneven market conditions.

Key complaints from excluded buyers include:

• Lack of transparency regarding selection criteria for discount eligibility
• Competitive disadvantages when selling to retailers against those with discounted inventory
• Being expected to purchase at full price while aware others receive substantial discounts
• Concerns about long-term business relationships with De Beers given the secretive approach

These tensions threaten the cohesiveness of De Beers' traditional buyer network and could potentially accelerate shifts toward alternative diamond sources.

Market Destabilization Concerns

Industry experts worry that as knowledge of these secret deals spreads, it could undermine confidence in De Beers' broader pricing structure and potentially accelerate market volatility. The diamond industry relies heavily on price stability and predictability, making these unusual transactions particularly disruptive to established business models.

The apparent disconnect between official prices and actual transaction values creates uncertainty throughout the supply chain, from miners to retailers. Market participants struggle to determine true diamond values when the industry's traditional price leader engages in contradictory practices—maintaining official rates while quietly transacting at substantial discounts.

Restructuring Signals

Adding to market anxiety, De Beers has informed clients it plans to reduce its customer base in 2026, creating another layer of uncertainty for current buyers. This pending reduction, combined with the selective discounting strategy, signals significant changes in how De Beers intends to operate moving forward.

Many industry observers interpret these moves as early indicators of a more fundamental restructuring of De Beers' sales approach, potentially ending decades of the traditional sightholder system. The prospect of such changes creates additional stress in a market already navigating multiple challenges.

What External Factors Are Complicating the Diamond Market?

Trump's Trade War Impact

The diamond industry faces additional challenges from President Donald Trump's trade policies. The current situation includes:

• A 10% tariff on all diamond imports to the United States
• Potential additional levies when the current 90-day pause on reciprocal tariffs expires
• Market disruption as traders rush inventory into the US ahead of possible tariff increases
• Slowing purchases as companies fear being stuck with inventory that's no longer profitable due to US tariff impacts

"Trump's tariffs threaten to increase consumer prices and reduce demand in the world's largest diamond market," reported Bloomberg, highlighting the compound challenges facing the industry. These trade tensions create particular challenges for an industry already struggling with weak consumer demand and inventory imbalances.

Global Supply Chain Vulnerabilities

The diamond industry's global structure makes it particularly vulnerable to trade disruptions and policy changes:

• The United States represents approximately 50% of global diamond consumption but mines no significant quantities domestically
• India processes approximately 90% of the world's diamonds through its cutting and polishing centers
• Diamonds typically cross multiple international borders before reaching consumers
• Profit margins at each stage of the supply chain have narrowed, leaving little buffer for additional costs

This international supply chain creates multiple points of exposure to trade policies, with changes in any major market potentially disrupting the entire system. The industry evolution trends and high degree of specialization by country makes it particularly vulnerable to targeted trade measures.

Industry Response to Trade Tensions

The diamond sector has launched coordinated lobbying efforts seeking exemptions from the tariffs. Industry organizations highlight the potential damage to a global industry already facing significant challenges, particularly given the central role of US consumers in sustaining the market.

Industry representatives argue that these additional costs could severely impact consumer demand in the crucial US market, potentially triggering a downward spiral of reduced sales, inventory buildups, and further price pressures throughout the global supply chain.

What Does This Mean for De Beers' Future?

Corporate Restructuring Efforts

De Beers is implementing aggressive cost-cutting measures beyond its selective sales strategy. Recently, the company announced the closure of its lab-grown diamond brand, Lightbox, as part of broader efforts to streamline operations and improve financial performance ahead of Anglo American's planned divestiture.

This move represents a significant strategic shift, as Lightbox had previously been positioned as De Beers' answer to the growing lab-grown diamond sector. The decision to shutter this operation signals both immediate cost pressures and potentially a refocusing on the company's core natural diamond business.

Market Position Challenges

De Beers' historical dominance in the diamond market faces unprecedented challenges from multiple directions:

• The growing gap between official prices and market reality undermines its price-setting authority
• Resistance from traditional customers to purchasing at above-market rates weakens its sales model
• Increased competition from other suppliers with more flexible pricing models erodes market share
• The need to balance inventory reduction with market stability creates operational contradictions
• Anglo American's divestment plans create uncertainty about future ownership and strategy

These overlapping challenges threaten the foundations of De Beers' traditional business model and may require more fundamental changes than the company has yet acknowledged publicly.

Strategic Pivot Possibilities

Industry analysts suggest De Beers may be forced to fundamentally rethink its sales model if current market conditions persist. Potential strategic shifts could include:

• Adopting more transparent pricing mechanisms that better reflect market realities
• Revising customer selection criteria to focus on fewer, more financially stable partners
• Restructuring sales events with greater flexibility in both pricing and purchase volumes
• Developing new approaches to inventory management that reduce carrying costs
• Potential vertical integration to capture more value from finished diamond sales

"De Beers may need to completely overhaul its sales model to survive in today's more fragmented and transparent market," noted industry observers in Bloomberg's May report, highlighting the existential nature of the challenges facing the company.

FAQs About the Diamond Market Crisis

Why doesn't De Beers simply lower its official prices?

De Beers avoids across-the-board price reductions because of its significant market influence. A public price cut from the industry's traditional leader could trigger industry-wide devaluation, potentially causing greater harm to the entire diamond ecosystem.

The company's historical role as a market stabilizer makes price maintenance a strategic priority, even when it creates short-term challenges. By maintaining official prices while offering selective discounts, De Beers attempts to preserve the appearance of market stability while addressing its own inventory challenges.

How are diamond retailers affected by these market dynamics?

Retailers face multiple challenges in the current environment:

• Uncertainty about wholesale pricing as the gap between official and actual transaction prices widens
• Potential consumer price increases due to tariffs that may reduce overall demand
• Questions about inventory valuation as market prices fluctuate unpredictably
• Competitive disadvantages if competitors source from suppliers receiving De Beers' discounts

Those purchasing from De Beers customers who received discounted diamonds may have significant competitive advantages over those buying from customers paying full price, creating market distortions that can dramatically impact retailers' ability to maintain margins.

What impact might the US-China trade war have on diamond prices?

The ongoing US‑China trade war could create several effects throughout the diamond supply chain:

• Higher consumer prices in the US market as tariff costs are passed through to customers
• Reduced overall demand if price increases exceed consumers' willingness to pay
• Supply chain disruptions as companies adjust sourcing strategies to minimize tariff exposure
• Potential market segmentation based on companies' ability to navigate tariff complexities

These trade policies add another layer of complexity to an industry already struggling with structural challenges, potentially accelerating changes in how diamonds are sourced, processed, and sold globally.

How unusual is De Beers' current sales approach?

Industry veterans describe the selective discounting strategy as nearly unprecedented in modern diamond market history. While De Beers has occasionally offered flexibility during severe market downturns, the current approach of maintaining official prices while offering substantial secret discounts to select customers represents a significant departure from traditional practices.

This unusual approach reflects both the severity of current market conditions and the complex pressures facing De Beers as it navigates both market challenges and corporate restructuring demands from its parent company.

Key Statistics and Market Data

"The diamond industry's current challenges reflect broader tensions between traditional market control mechanisms and the realities of a rapidly evolving global marketplace. De Beers' attempt to maintain price stability while secretly offering discounts highlights the difficult balance between supporting the overall market and addressing immediate business pressures."

Industry Outlook and Analysis

The developments at De Beers signal potential fundamental changes in how the diamond industry operates. While the market has weathered previous downturns, the combination of changing consumer preferences, trade tensions, and corporate restructuring pressures create unprecedented challenges.

Diamond industry participants across the supply chain should prepare for continued volatility as De Beers navigates its competing priorities. The outcome of Anglo American's divestment plans will likely determine whether De Beers maintains its traditional approach or pivots to a fundamentally different business model.

For investors and industry stakeholders, these developments highlight the importance of adaptability and diversification in a market undergoing structural transformation. The traditional certainties of the diamond industry—stable pricing, predictable supply channels, and established customer relationships—appear increasingly vulnerable to both market forces and corporate strategic shifts. Furthermore, countries with significant diamond resources like South Africa beneficiation initiatives could impact how value is distributed across the global supply chain.

The global tariff market impacts may further complicate De Beers' strategic decision-making, especially as trade policies continue to evolve in major consumer markets.

Disclaimer: This analysis reflects current market conditions and available information as of May 2025. The diamond industry remains in flux, and future developments may significantly alter market dynamics and corporate strategies.

Investing in Diamond Stocks During Market Uncertainty?

Stay ahead of market shifts in the mining sector with real-time alerts on significant ASX mineral discoveries, powered by Discovery Alert's proprietary Discovery IQ model. Visit Discovery Alert's discoveries page to understand how major mineral discoveries can lead to exceptional returns, and begin your 30-day free trial today.