The One Reason to Buy Gold Stocks, According to Agnico Eagle CEO

Why Should You Buy Gold Mining Stocks? Understanding Value Beyond Bullion

When it comes to investing in precious metals, many investors face a critical choice: physical gold or gold mining stocks? While gold bullion offers a direct hedge against inflation and economic uncertainty, gold mining stocks present a potentially more lucrative—though riskier—opportunity for those seeking exposure to the gold market.

According to Ammar Al-Joundi, CEO of Agnico Eagle Mines, the investment thesis for gold stocks is remarkably straightforward: "The only reason you want to buy an equity is if it gives you a better return than just buying gold." This candid assessment from one of the industry's leading executives crystallizes the fundamental value proposition that gold miners must deliver to attract investor capital.

In a market where gold itself has risen 44% over the past year, the bar for mining companies to outperform the underlying commodity is increasingly high. Yet some companies, like Agnico Eagle with its impressive 84% stock price increase during the same period, demonstrate that exceptional operational execution can indeed create superior returns.

The Single Compelling Reason to Invest in Gold Stocks

The investment case for gold mining stocks hinges on a single compelling argument: operational leverage. When gold prices rise, mining companies can often experience disproportionately larger increases in profitability and free cash flow. A 10% increase in gold prices might translate to a 20-30% increase in operating margins for a low-cost producer, potentially driving even larger stock price appreciation.

This mathematical advantage represents the primary allure of gold stocks over physical gold. However, this leverage works in both directions—when gold prices fall, mining stocks typically decline more severely than the metal itself.

How Gold Stocks Compare to Physical Gold

Gold mining stocks and physical gold represent fundamentally different investment vehicles with distinct risk-reward profiles:

• Operational leverage: Mining stocks offer amplified exposure to gold price movements
• Income potential: Many miners pay dividends, providing income streams that physical gold cannot
• Growth opportunity: Well-managed companies can increase production and reserves over time
• Management factor: Company leadership decisions directly impact shareholder returns
• Geopolitical exposure: Mining operations face country-specific regulatory and political risks

Physical gold, meanwhile, offers these contrasting attributes:

• Direct commodity exposure: No operational risks or management concerns
• Permanent value: Gold maintains intrinsic value regardless of corporate performance
• Liquidity: Physical gold and gold ETFs offer straightforward buying/selling processes
• Simplicity: No need to analyze financial statements or assess management teams
• Portfolio insurance: Historically performs well during periods of market stress

The optimal approach often involves strategically combining both investment types to achieve balanced exposure to the gold stock market guide.

Why Do Gold Mining Stocks Often Underperform?

Despite the theoretical advantage of operational leverage, the gold mining industry has a checkered history of delivering shareholder value. Even with gold reaching record prices, many investors remain skeptical of the sector's ability to capitalize on favorable market conditions.

Historical Underperformance Patterns

The numbers tell a sobering story about gold mining investments. According to industry data, approximately 25% of stocks in the 56-member VanEck Gold Miners ETF underperformed gold itself in 2025, despite ideal market conditions with rising gold prices analysis. This underperformance isn't a new phenomenon—it reflects a troubling pattern across multiple gold price cycles.

Even more concerning, the sector has experienced significant ETF outflows despite record gold prices, indicating investor skepticism about miners' ability to translate high commodity prices into shareholder returns. This lack of confidence stems from a well-documented history of value destruction.

Perhaps most damning is the collective $50 billion in asset writedowns the industry has recorded since 2013—a staggering admission of overvalued acquisitions and poor capital allocation decisions that destroyed shareholder value.

Poor Capital Allocation Decisions

The gold mining industry's reputation has been tarnished by a recurring pattern of questionable management decisions, particularly during periods of high gold prices. When cash flows surge during gold bull markets, mining executives have often fallen prey to several value-destroying temptations:

1. Empire building: Acquiring competitors at premium valuations that rarely deliver projected synergies
2. Project overexpansion: Developing marginal deposits that become unprofitable when gold prices normalize
3. Reserve replacement at any cost: Paying excessive premiums for exploration companies
4. Operational inefficiencies: Focusing on production volume over profitability
5. Balance sheet deterioration: Taking on excessive debt to fund aggressive growth plans

These decisions typically occur near cyclical peaks, leaving companies vulnerable when gold prices inevitably retreat. The subsequent asset impairments, equity dilution, and dividend cuts create a legacy of disappointed investors.

Investor Perception Issues

The cumulative effect of these historical missteps has created a profound image problem for the gold mining sector. As Al-Joundi bluntly describes it: "If some of us are blowing our brains out, they look at us and say, 'That's a crappy industry, I'm not even going to look at it.'"

This negative perception has concrete consequences for the entire sector:

• Lower overall valuation multiples compared to other resource industries
• Increased investor skepticism during gold price rallies
• Higher equity risk premiums demanded by institutional investors
• Greater scrutiny of capital allocation decisions
• Preference for physical gold or royalty companies over traditional miners

Breaking this cycle of mistrust requires a fundamental shift in how mining companies approach capital allocation, operational discipline, and shareholder returns.

How Are Leading Gold Miners Performing?

The performance disparity among major gold producers reveals that company-specific execution matters significantly, even within the same industry facing identical gold prices.

Agnico Eagle's Market Outperformance

Agnico Eagle has emerged as the clear standout among major gold producers, with performance metrics that have redefined what's possible in the gold mining sector:

• Stock appreciation: 84% increase over the past year, dramatically outpacing gold's 44% gain
• Peer comparison: More than doubled the performance of major competitors Barrick and Newmont
• Valuation premium: Achieved industry-leading price-to-earnings ratio of 25x (compared to Newmont's 14x and Barrick's 9x)
• Market recognition: Surpassed rivals in market capitalization despite a smaller production profile

This exceptional performance demonstrates that investors will reward mining companies that consistently deliver on operational promises and maintain capital discipline across market cycles.

Competitive Landscape Analysis

The stark performance divergence among top gold miners reveals significant valuation disparities that reflect investor perceptions of management quality and capital allocation discipline:

This performance divergence underscores that gold mining stocks are not homogeneous investments—company-specific execution, asset quality, and management approaches create dramatically different shareholder outcomes, even within the same commodity price environment.

What Are Investors Looking for in Gold Stocks?

Understanding investor expectations is crucial for both mining company executives and potential shareholders evaluating the sector.

Value Creation Fundamentals

Greg Taylor, chief investment officer at Penderfund Capital Management, offers a sobering assessment: the gold mining sector "hasn't been a long-term creator of value." To change this perception and attract sustained investment, companies must demonstrate:

• Capital discipline: Maintaining investment discipline during periods of high gold prices
• Operational excellence: Consistently meeting production and cost guidance
• Shareholder returns: Establishing sustainable dividend policies aligned with cash flow generation
• Balance sheet strength: Maintaining financial flexibility across market cycles
• Reserve replacement: Finding new ounces at reasonable costs to extend mine life
• ESG leadership: Proactively addressing environmental and social concerns

The companies that successfully address these priorities tend to trade at premium valuations compared to peers that struggle with execution or discipline.

Alternative Investment Approaches

Many investors seeking gold exposure have increasingly bypassed traditional miners in favor of alternative vehicles that offer gold price exposure with different risk profiles:

• Physical gold ETFs: Provide direct commodity exposure without operational risks
• Precious metals royalty companies: Offer diversified mining exposure with superior margins
• Junior explorers: Provide higher-risk, higher-reward potential through discovery upside
• Private equity: Investing in private mining assets with longer time horizons
• Tactical trading: Using mining stocks as trading vehicles rather than long-term investments

The popularity of these alternatives reflects investor frustration with the historical underperformance of traditional gold producers. As Taylor notes, "Generalist investors currently prefer to buy and hold either physical gold or precious metals royalty companies" rather than commit to conventional mining equities.

How Can Gold Mining Companies Improve Their Investment Appeal?

The path to higher valuations and broader investor interest requires fundamental changes in how gold mining companies operate and allocate capital.

Disciplined Financial Management

To attract broader investor interest and command premium valuations, gold miners should prioritize:

1. Capital expenditure discipline: Maintaining investment discipline even during gold price rallies
2. Acquisition restraint: Avoiding dilutive share issuances for questionable acquisitions
3. Project hurdle rates: Establishing clear return on investment thresholds that account for commodity price cyclicality
4. Transparent shareholder returns: Implementing dividend policies tied to free cash flow generation
5. Counter-cyclical planning: Building cash reserves during strong markets to weather downturns or fund opportunistic acquisitions

Companies that maintain this discipline across market cycles tend to outperform peers who succumb to the temptation of aggressive expansion during periods of high gold prices.

Industry-Wide Valuation Benefits

Al-Joundi advocates for industry-wide discipline, noting that responsible behavior by all major gold miners would benefit the entire sector: "Industry-wide discipline would benefit the entire sector… leading to higher overall industry valuations."

This collective approach could transform investor perception of the mining sector:

• Valuation expansion: Higher overall industry valuations would result from collective discipline
• Investor confidence: Reduced skepticism from generalist investors toward the mining sector
• Sustainable premiums: Potential for sustained premium valuations relative to commodity prices
• Reduced volatility: Greater stability in company share prices during gold price fluctuations
• Broader ownership: Increased interest from ESG-focused and long-term investors

The challenge lies in overcoming the competitive dynamics and short-term pressures that have historically led to value-destroying decisions during gold bull markets.

What Are Current Market Trends for Gold and Mining Stocks?

Understanding the current market environment provides essential context for evaluating gold mining investments in 2025.

Gold Price Drivers in 2025

Gold has reached record price levels in 2025 due to a confluence of supportive factors:

• Economic uncertainty: Concerns related to tariff policies and trade tensions
• Geopolitical instability: Escalating tensions in multiple global regions
• Fiscal concerns: Growing apprehension about U.S. debt sustainability
• Monetary policy shifts: Potential changes in central bank policies affecting interest rates
• Safe-haven demand: Increased investor allocation to traditional safe-haven assets
• Physical demand: Strong central bank buying supporting price fundamentals
• Supply constraints: Peak gold production theories gaining credibility as discovery rates decline

This supportive price environment creates an ideal operating backdrop for mining companies to generate substantial free cash flow—if they maintain operational discipline.

Emerging Positive Signs

There are encouraging indications that the current gold bull market might produce different outcomes for mining companies compared to previous cycles:

• Improved discipline: Taylor notes this cycle has been "more encouraging" with fewer questionable decisions
• Operational focus: Companies emphasizing operational excellence rather than merely expanding production
• Balance sheet strength: Reduced leverage across the sector providing financial flexibility
• Return of capital: Increased emphasis on shareholder returns through dividends and buybacks
• ESG integration: Greater attention to environmental and social considerations in project development
• Technological adoption: Implementation of automation and data analytics to improve efficiency

These positive developments suggest the potential for mining companies to better translate high gold prices into sustainable shareholder returns, potentially breaking the historical pattern of underperformance.

How Should Investors Approach Gold Mining Stocks?

Given the complex dynamics of gold mining investments, investors need a structured framework for evaluating opportunities in the sector.

Strategic Investment Considerations

When evaluating gold mining investments, consider these key factors:

1. Management track record: Assess the company's capital allocation history across different price environments
2. Operational consistency: Evaluate the company's record of meeting production and cost guidance
3. Asset quality: Analyze the grade, jurisdiction, and mine life of key producing assets
4. Cost position: Compare all-in sustaining costs (AISC) relative to industry peers
5. Balance sheet strength: Assess debt levels, maturity schedules, and financial flexibility
6. Growth pipeline: Evaluate organic growth opportunities and their capital requirements
7. Dividend policy: Consider the sustainability and growth potential of dividend payments
8. Valuation metrics: Compare P/NAV, P/CF, and EV/EBITDA multiples to historical ranges and peers

These factors provide a comprehensive framework for identifying undervalued gold stocks with the potential to outperform both the sector and the underlying commodity.

Balancing Portfolio Exposure

A balanced approach to gold sector investment might include:

• Core holdings: Physical gold or gold ETFs (10-15% of precious metals allocation)
• Quality producers: Established miners with proven management teams (40-50%)
• Royalty companies: Lower-risk exposure through Franco-Nevada or similar (20-30%)
• Exploration upside: Selective junior miners with discovery potential (5-10%)
• Tactical allocation: Adjusting weightings based on gold price forecast and relative valuations

This diversified approach provides comprehensive exposure to the gold sector while mitigating the specific risks associated with individual mining operations.

What Does the Future Hold for Gold Mining Investments?

The gold mining sector stands at a critical juncture, with the potential to either repeat historical mistakes or establish a new paradigm of disciplined growth and shareholder returns.

Industry Evolution Potential

The gold mining sector has an opportunity to transform its reputation through:

• Operational innovation: Implementing new technologies to improve productivity and safety
• Responsible consolidation: Pursuing value-accretive mergers that create genuine synergies
• ESG leadership: Setting new standards for environmental stewardship and community relations
• Transparent communication: Building credibility through consistent operational execution
• Balanced growth: Pursuing reserve replacement without sacrificing return requirements
• Countercyclical strategy: Leveraging strong balance sheets during industry downturns

These evolutionary steps could fundamentally change how investors perceive and value gold mining companies, potentially narrowing the historical performance gap with physical gold.

Long-Term Value Proposition

Even Al-Joundi acknowledges the symbiotic relationship between gold and gold miners: "I would encourage people to buy the hard asset because, at the end of the day, that's good for us as well." This perspective recognizes that a healthy gold market creates the foundation for mining company success.

For long-term investors, the optimal approach likely combines:

"A strategic allocation to physical gold provides portfolio insurance and stability, while selective investments in well-managed mining companies offer the potential for superior returns during favorable market conditions." — Industry consensus view

This balanced approach acknowledges both the historical challenges of mining investments and their potential for exceptional performance when operational execution meets favorable gold market trends.

FAQs About Gold Mining Investments

Why have gold mining stocks historically underperformed gold?

Gold mining companies have often squandered opportunities during bull markets through poor capital allocation, overpriced acquisitions, and operational inefficiencies. The industry has written down approximately $50 billion in assets since 2013, reflecting widespread value destruction through poor investment decisions. This pattern has created persistent investor skepticism about the sector's ability to translate high gold prices into sustainable shareholder returns.

What differentiates successful gold mining companies from underperformers?

Top-performing gold miners maintain disciplined capital allocation regardless of gold price environments, focus relentlessly on operational excellence, establish sustainable dividend policies tied to cash flow generation, and avoid dilutive transactions during market peaks. Agnico Eagle exemplifies this approach, achieving an 84% stock price increase over the past year and commanding an industry-leading P/E ratio of 25x compared to Barrick's 9x and Newmont's 14x.

Should investors choose gold ETFs or mining stocks?

The decision depends on investment objectives, risk tolerance, and market outlook. Gold ETFs provide direct commodity exposure with lower operational risk and greater simplicity, while select mining stocks offer potential outperformance through operational leverage

Ready to Capitalise on the Next Major Gold Discovery?

Discovery Alert's proprietary Discovery IQ model instantly notifies investors of significant ASX mineral discoveries, including gold, transforming complex data into actionable opportunities before the market reacts. Explore why major discoveries can lead to substantial returns by visiting the Discovery Alert discoveries page and begin your 30-day free trial today.