What Is the Historical Relationship Between Gold and the Stock Market?

The relationship between gold and the stock market has historically been characterized by inverse correlation patterns, especially during significant market transitions. While these assets can rise together during certain periods, their relative performance reveals important secular trends that smart investors can capitalize on. Understanding this gold-stock market guide can provide valuable insights for portfolio diversification.

The Mid-1960s Analog: A Key Historical Comparison

The period between 1964-1968 offers remarkably valuable insights for today's market conditions. Many analysts point to 2008 or other recent market cycles, but the mid-1960s present a more compelling analog for several structural reasons.

During the 1960s, direct gold ownership was restricted for Americans, making gold stocks the primary proxy for precious metals exposure. The Barron's Gold Mining Index broke out decisively in late 1964, establishing a multi-year uptrend that would continue through the decade. This breakout pattern bears striking resemblance to gold's cup and handle breakout pattern that completed in 2023, suggesting we may be at a similar inflection point in the gold-equity relationship.

Perhaps most tellingly, the stock market peaks in 1966 (Dow Jones Industrial Average) and 1968 (S&P 500) showed only about a 20% difference between them. This staggered peaking process gave investors who recognized the shift from stocks to gold an opportunity to reposition their portfolios before the major decline.

"The 1960s featured comparable bond market dynamics and gold's emergence as a preferred asset during a period of rising inflation concerns—unlike 2008, which was primarily a deflationary crisis," notes Jordan from The Daily Gold.

How Bond Markets Influence Both Assets

Bond market performance serves as a critical indicator—perhaps the most important one—for understanding both stock market and gold trends. Technical analysis of bonds can provide early warning signals that neither gold nor stock charts reveal on their own.

The 80-month moving average of total real bond returns has proven particularly significant. This indicator marked secular peaks in both the 1960s and our current markets with remarkable accuracy. In the late 1960s, when this moving average was permanently lost, it coincided almost perfectly with the secular peak in stocks and preceded a massive gold bull market.

Current bond market conditions show similar warning signs to the pre-bear market period of the 1960s. The breakdown below this critical 80-month moving average suggests that despite short-term stock market resilience, we may be witnessing a major macro-economic transition favoring gold over equities.

Key technical insight: When bond markets enter secular bear markets, stock valuations typically compress while gold enters a secular bull market. This relationship held true in the late 1960s through the 1970s and appears to be repeating today, with many analysts predicting a favorable gold price forecast for the coming years.

How Do Interest Rates Impact Gold and Stocks?

Interest rates form the foundation of financial market valuations, affecting both stocks and gold—though in different ways and with different thresholds for impact.

Critical Interest Rate Thresholds

Historical analysis reveals specific interest rate levels that act as triggering mechanisms for major market shifts. During the mid-1960s market cycle, the 10-year Treasury yield crossing 5% coincided almost perfectly with the 1966 stock market peak. Later, when yields stabilized above 5.5% in the late 1960s, the stock market reached its secular peak and entered a prolonged period of underperformance relative to gold.

As of May 2025, current 10-year yields hover near 4.5%—notably below these historical threshold levels, but trending upward. This suggests potential runway remaining for the stock market's advance, at least in nominal terms.

"It's not the initial interest rate increases that hurt stocks," explains Jordan of The Daily Gold, "but reaching certain thresholds like 5-5.5% that trigger broader economic problems and compress equity valuations."

This perspective offers a more nuanced understanding than the simplistic "rising rates hurt stocks" narrative often promoted in financial media. The relationship involves specific thresholds rather than just directional moves, as explained in detail by Investopedia's analysis of gold price drivers.

The Recession Factor

Rising long-term interest rates above key thresholds historically precede recessions—though often with significant time lags. The transmission mechanism typically works through the housing market, corporate borrowing costs, and consumer credit markets, which eventually impact corporate earnings and stock valuations.

Current yield trends suggest monitoring for potential moves toward the 5% threshold, as crossing this level could signal increased recession risk in the 12-24 months following. However, the ongoing economic resilience against recession forces (including strong employment data through early 2025) could allow stocks to continue rising in the near term despite interest rate pressures.

The timing between interest rate thresholds being crossed and actual market peaks can vary considerably—sometimes by months or even years. This variability makes precise market timing difficult but doesn't negate the importance of monitoring these thresholds for strategic portfolio positioning.

What Technical Indicators Show About Gold vs. Stocks?

Technical analysis provides objective metrics for evaluating the relative performance between gold and stocks, offering insights beyond fundamental economic data.

Key Moving Averages and Their Significance

The 40-month moving average serves as a powerful secular trend indicator for the stock market. Throughout history, bull markets typically remain above this moving average while bear markets occur below it. Recent stock market corrections approached but didn't break decisively below this critical level, suggesting the current bull market structure remains technically intact despite significant volatility.

Meanwhile, the previously mentioned 80-month moving average of total real bond returns shows a clear secular bear market in bonds—a condition that historically favors gold over stocks for extended periods.

Perhaps most significantly, both the 40-month and 80-month moving averages confirm the secular breakdown in stocks relative to gold. This technical confirmation provides strong evidence that a major shift in asset performance is underway, similar to patterns observed in the mid-1960s.

Technical analysts note: These longer-term moving averages filter out short-term noise and reveal the underlying secular trends that typically persist for years or even decades.

S&P 500 to Gold Ratio Analysis

The S&P 500 to gold ratio has clearly broken down below multi-year support, currently trading around 176 (as of May 2025). This represents a decisive technical breakdown below the 11-12 year support level that had previously contained declines.

While the current ratio shows a counter-trend bounce that could continue short-term (potentially approaching the 216 level), the ratio has broken below both its 40-month and 80-month moving averages, confirming a secular breakdown in stocks relative to gold.

This pattern resembles what occurred in 1964-1965 when gold stocks broke out against the broader market. Back then, stocks managed to make marginal new highs after the initial gold breakout, but gold and gold stocks dramatically outperformed equities over the subsequent decade, eventually leading to record-breaking gold prices similar to what we're seeing today.

"When examining the S&P 500 to gold ratio chart, we're seeing a clear breakdown below major support. Counter-trend rallies are normal, but the technical damage suggests we've entered a multi-year period where gold outperforms stocks." — Jordan, The Daily Gold

What Could Happen to Gold if Stocks Continue Rising?

Many investors worry that continued stock market strength might undermine the case for gold. Historical analysis suggests this concern may be misplaced, as both can rise simultaneously while gold still maintains relative outperformance.

Short-Term Consolidation Scenario

Gold may continue consolidating if stocks rally for several more months. This wouldn't negate gold's structural breakout but could delay its next major advance. During such periods, gold typically trades sideways or makes modest advances while stocks outperform temporarily.

Counter-trend moves in the S&P 500 to gold ratio could persist temporarily, potentially approaching the 216 level before resuming its downtrend. This would represent a normal retracement within the context of a new secular trend favoring gold.

Even with stock market strength, gold has already achieved key breakouts against the traditional 60/40 portfolio (60% stocks, 40% bonds). This significant technical development suggests gold's secular bull market remains intact regardless of short-term stock market performance.

The cup and handle pattern breakout in gold that completed in 2023 remains technically valid despite stock market resilience. Such patterns typically resolve with substantial advances once consolidation periods conclude.

Long-Term Bullish Case for Gold

Gold is positioned favorably even if stocks make marginal new highs in the coming months. The breakdown in the S&P 500 to gold ratio below 11-12 year support represents a significant technical event that typically precedes major shifts in relative performance.

When the current counter-trend move ends, gold could see dramatic price appreciation. Historical precedents suggest potential for gold to reach $5,000+ when stocks eventually peak and the ratio plunges to new lows, potentially reaching a historic gold milestone in the process.

• The S&P 500 to gold ratio reached approximately 6 at the 1980 gold peak
• It fell to nearly 1 at the 2011 gold high
• Even a decline to the 4-5 range would imply gold prices above $5,000

Geological perspective: Unlike stocks, which can be created continuously, gold production remains constrained by declining ore grades and increasing extraction costs. This supply limitation becomes particularly significant during periods of heightened demand.

How Can Investors Interpret These Market Signals?

Translating market signals into actionable investment strategies requires distinguishing between short-term noise and long-term secular trends.

Recognizing Secular vs. Cyclical Trends

It's essential to distinguish between short-term counter-trend moves (which can last months) and long-term secular trends (which typically persist for years or decades). Many investors make the mistake of abandoning sound long-term positioning due to short-term market movements.

The stock market could make new highs while still underperforming gold on a relative basis. This occurred in the late 1960s when stocks reached new nominal highs but lost significant ground when measured against gold.

Current market conditions suggest we're in the early stages of a major gold bull market that could last 5-10 years. While this doesn't mean stocks will necessarily crash immediately, it does suggest that gold deserves a more prominent position in investment portfolios than it has during the past decade, especially considering recent all-time high gold analysis.

Historical patterns suggest stocks could make marginal new highs before a significant decline. This "final push" often occurs before major market tops, creating a false sense of security among equity investors.

Portfolio Positioning Considerations

Gold has already broken out against traditional 60/40 portfolios, suggesting that even conservative investors should consider increasing their precious metals allocation. The traditional portfolio mix that worked well during the 40-year bond bull market may be significantly less effective in the current environment.

Current consolidation in gold presents potential accumulation opportunities for investors looking to establish or increase positions. These consolidation phases typically precede major advances once they resolve.

Stock market strength doesn't negate the long-term bullish case for precious metals. In fact, history shows that gold often experiences its strongest gains after periods of stock market strength when the eventual rotation from equities to safe havens begins.

The eventual breakdown in stocks relative to gold could trigger substantial gold appreciation. This suggests investors should consider:

1. Maintaining core gold positions despite short-term fluctuations
2. Using stock market strength to strategically reduce equity exposure
3. Viewing gold consolidation periods as potential buying opportunities
4. Focusing on mining companies with strong production growth and reasonable valuations

"Portfolio positioning should reflect the secular trend, not short-term market noise. The breakdown in the S&P 500 to gold ratio below multi-year support suggests allocating more to gold than most conventional models recommend." — Jordan, The Daily Gold

FAQs About Gold and Stock Market Relationships

Why is the 1960s comparison more relevant than other historical periods?

The 1960s featured similar macroeconomic conditions to today, including rising interest rates, inflation concerns, and a transition from a long-term bull market in bonds to a secular bear market. Unlike other periods such as 2008 that many analysts reference, the 1960s featured comparable bond market dynamics and gold's emergence as a preferred asset.

Additionally, the 1960s saw a similar sequence of peaks across different assets—bonds peaked first, followed by stocks, followed by a substantial gold bull market. This pattern appears to be repeating today, with bonds having already entered a secular bear market.

The 1960s also featured a gradual loss of faith in government monetary management, similar to concerns emerging today about central bank policies and sovereign debt levels.

How might central bank policies affect the gold-stock relationship?

Central bank policies influence interest rates, which directly impact both gold and stocks. If central banks maintain accommodative policies despite inflation, stocks may continue rising while gold consolidates. However, if rates continue climbing toward the critical 5-5.5% threshold, this could trigger both economic weakness and accelerated gold appreciation.

Central bank gold purchases represent another significant factor. Central banks globally have been net buyers of gold since 2010, with purchases accelerating in recent years. This demand source didn't exist during previous gold bull markets and could amplify price movements.

The effectiveness of central bank policies in managing inflation expectations will play a crucial role. If markets perceive central banks as falling behind the inflation curve, gold could benefit disproportionately, even during periods of stock market strength.

What signals would confirm the end of gold's consolidation phase?

A decisive breakdown in the S&P 500 to gold ratio below its 11-12 year support level would signal the end of consolidation. Additionally, gold breaking to new all-time highs while stocks struggle would confirm the next major leg up in the gold bull market.

Technical indicators to monitor include:

• Gold breaking above its previous all-time high with strong volume
• Mining stocks outperforming physical gold (typically occurs during strong bull markets)
• Silver outperforming gold (the gold:silver ratio declining)
• Increased mainstream media coverage of gold investments

These signals typically emerge sequentially rather than simultaneously, with technical breakouts preceding broader public interest.

How might geopolitical tensions affect the gold-stock relationship?

Geopolitical tensions typically benefit gold more than stocks, as investors seek safe-haven assets during uncertainty. Such events could accelerate the breakdown in the S&P 500 to gold ratio and potentially trigger gold's move toward $5,000 and beyond.

Recent tensions including trade disputes, resource nationalism, and currency conflicts all favor gold as a neutral, internationally recognized store of value. Unlike stocks, gold has no counterparty risk and has maintained its purchasing power through numerous geopolitical crises throughout history, as documented by the World Gold Council.

Regulatory perspective: Increasing regulatory pressures on the banking and financial sectors tend to increase compliance costs and reduce profitability for stocks, while simultaneously enhancing gold's appeal as an asset outside the traditional financial system.

The interplay between geopolitical events and monetary policy responses is particularly significant. When central banks respond to geopolitical crises with increased liquidity, this often benefits both assets initially but gold more substantially in the longer term.

Further Exploration

Investors interested in understanding the dynamics between the stock market and gold should consider monitoring both absolute and relative performance metrics. While headlines often focus on nominal price movements, the relationship between these assets often reveals more about underlying economic conditions than either asset viewed in isolation.

Technical analysis of the S&P 500 to gold ratio provides particular insight during major market transitions. This ratio has broken key support levels and appears to be starting a major downtrend favoring gold—a development with significant implications for portfolio construction in the years ahead.

As both monetary and fiscal policies continue evolving globally, the historical relationship between gold and stocks offers valuable guidance for navigating an increasingly complex investment landscape.

Ready to Position Your Portfolio for the Next Major Gold Bull Market?

Discover how major mineral discoveries could significantly boost your investment returns by exploring Discovery Alert's dedicated discoveries page, where their proprietary Discovery IQ model provides instant alerts on significant ASX mineral announcements, transforming complex data into actionable investment opportunities.